Eric Welsh recently spoke to Bloomberg Tax about the ongoing challenges facing those going through the naturalization process as the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) more heavily scrutinizes tax records. The article, “Citizenship Hurdles Pile Up as DHS Puts Taxes Under Microscope,” examines a recent policy shift at United States Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) as it moves away from the “good moral character” standard–a requirement since the first naturalization law passed in the 18th century.
Last year, a policy memorandum directed USCIS officers to take a “holistic” approach to evaluating good moral character, including compliance with tax obligations, as well as community involvement and educational background. Prior to the memo, tax-related charges or convictions weren’t utilized throughout the process.
Naturalization rates are plummeting, with many denials issued based solely on established payment plans or filed tax extensions. USCIS describes failure to fully pay tax obligations as an unlawful act.
“[Extensions and payment plans] do not per se indicate that a person lacks good moral character,” Welsh tells Bloomberg Tax. “That’s the problem with the good moral character standard, they’re so fuzzy.”
Read the full article in Bloomberg Tax (subscription required).